The mystery of mount points
This article explains the concept of mount points but I hope
the article has also some information which is interesting to
readers who are not new to linux.
_________________ _________________ _________________
I will first explain the concept of mounting file-systems and
then come to more advanced features. If you feel that you are
already a Linux expert then you can start to read a bit further
How it works
Under windows you have even until today the problem that adding
a new drive will mess up all the naming conventions. What used
to be D: drive is suddenly E: and users as well as software
gets confused about it.
Under Unix you will never have this problem because all the
physical disks are inserted into the directory tree. You can
see this if you type "mount" or "df":
Here we have two disk partition one which contains everything
except /home. This is the root partition "/" and it is physically
connected to hda1. hda1 is the first partition (1) on the first
ide harddisk (hda). The third partition (hda3) on the same disk
is mounted on /home. Thus if you go to /home then you access
files on hda3. You will never have to worry if this is now D:
or E: or ??? It is always just a directory tree and it is
always the same.
Filesystem 1K-blocks Used Available Use% Mounted on
/dev/hda1 9070728 4701180 3908768 55% /
/dev/hda3 24950428 683412 22999584 3% /home
none 257236 0 257236 0% /dev/shm
/dev/hda1 on / type ext3 (rw)
none on /proc type proc (rw)
none on /dev/shm type tmpfs (rw)
/dev/hda3 on /home type ext3 (rw)
The file-system busy problem
Linux buffers file system read and write operations. You will
notice this when you have usb version 1.1 disk and you access a
big file. The first time access is slow but the second time you
open the same file it is very very fast the the light on the
usb disk does not flash.
Because of this feature you can not just remove a disk that is
used. You need to unmount it. For normal internal harddisks
this is never an issue but it can be a problem for cdrom drives
and USB disks.
If you e.g mount a usb-stick under /mnt/usb and you do "cd
/mnt/usb" then bash is using this filesystem. If you then try
to umount it from a different shell window you will get "file
system busy" and the umount will fail. It is enough to "cd"
again out from the /mnt/usb and you can umount it. The problem
is sometimes you forgot who is using it and you have so many
applications open that it is difficult to find out what is
causing the umount to fail.
Ask your computer!
# fuser -m -u /mnt/usb
/mnt/usb: 1347c(root) 1348c(guido) 1349c(guido)
What you get from the fuser command is a list of processes
still using the filesystem in question. Now you can check with
"ps auxw" what this is or you can just kill them. After that
umount will work.
But windows can do it!?
Why not just pull out the usb-stick? Well, old dos/win3.1
computers could just be powered off. No shutdown needed. At
that time some of my friends complained that you had to
shutdown Linux before powering off. Then win95 came and those
complains were gone because everybody was used to shut down the
Linux can do it too!
There are also solutions for Linux to be able to just pull out
the disk (e.g a usb disk). Mandrake Linux has a feature called
supermount and it gives exactly the same results (or problems)
as windows. But I don't recommend it because it can cause
instability and lost files.
It is better to use the mtools (http://mtools.linux.lu/).
mtools are a set of commands to access floppy drives,
usb-sticks ... basically any removable media with a FAT
filesytem and you do not need to mount the filesystem.
Here is the trick:
Very easy to use.
Edit /etc/mtools.conf and add a line that says
drive u: file="/dev/sda1" # or sda4; some usb-stick have partition
# 4 created as factory default.
- Now you do NOT mount /dev/sda1. Instead you just type
to see what is on the usb-stick.
mcopy * u:
to copy all the files in the current directory to the
mcopy u:\* .
to copy all files from the usb-stick to the current directory
(note the \ in front of the wildcard).
Allow anybody to mount a filesystem
Normally you need to be user root to mount filesystems. For
devices like cdrom or usb-stick you might want to give any user
the right to mount them. All you need to do in this case, is to
add a line like this to /etc/fstab:
# dev mount point fs type flags
/dev/sda1 /mnt/usb auto noauto,user 0 0
This line means that sda1 (the first partition on the first scsi
disk, usb storage disks are mapped to scsi disks) shall not be
mounted automatically at startup (noauto) and can be
mounted/umounted by anybody (user). The FS-type field is also
set to auto so you can mount a usb-stick formatted with vfat or
ext2 and the right filesystem will be detected automatically.
Laptops and nfs
The network file system, NFS, is really good if you want to
have centralized backup of home directories for several users.
All you need to do is mount the home directories from a central
server and all users have their individual home directories
available on all the computers in the network. The same setting
and preferences and the same data everywhere. It's really good.
But how do we handle mobile users with Laptops? (no backups?)
Once you are off the network your home directory is gone. One
solution is to always copy all data (rsync) but this can easily
lead to inconsistency if you are not very disciplined and often
you do not need your full home directory. I find it a good
solution to have a second small home directory with just the
settings and data I need when I travel.
When you mount a filesystem (any filesystem/disk including nfs)
on a non empty directory then the content of this directory
becomes invisible and you see the mounted filesystem.
This is the solution: Create the mount point for the home
directories (/home) and automount there the different home
directories when the computer is on the net. However before you
mount anything create a softlink for the user that owns the
Laptop to an off-line home directory:
/home/guido -> ../home_nonet/guido
When user guido is on the network then he will see his normal
home directory because the softlink is shaded out. When he is on the road then he will see
/home_nonet/guido as his home directory (/home/guido).
A very nice solution.
To build an abstraction layer for the hardware has always been
one of the goals of Unix. To to mount/umount filesystem/disks
was one of the ways to achieve this. A really advanced and
modern idea even tough Unix is much older then other modern PC
Talkback form for this article
Every article has its own talkback page. On this page you can submit a comment or look at comments from other readers:
2004-10-15, generated by lfparser version 2.50